The Legal Difference Between Closed and Open Work Permits in Canada

Canada is a place where foreign workers seek new employment opportunities, and it can be disorienting to learn the regulations governing work permits. There are various types of work permits issued in Canada, and the most commonly used ones are closed work permits and open work permits. These permits are not alike regarding conditions and legal implications and it is important that any foreign worker seeking employment in Canada knows the difference. Learning of the way these permits operate can also prevent errors that could impinge on legal status, career prospects or subsequent applications to permanent residency.

Closed Work Permits Definition

A closed work permit is one form of authorization that bonds the foreign worker to one employer. It is generally issued when an employer has been granted a Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) indicating that no Canadian citizen or permanent resident is available to work in the job. The employee is limited to that particular job, employer, and place that is shown on the permit.

Due to the employer-specific nature of closed work permits, they can offer both an employer and a worker certain stability. But they also generate constraints. When a worker loses his job or wishes to change his employers they have to apply to get a new permit. A failure to do so can lead to a loss of legal status in Canada and this may have long-term implications to any future immigration plans.

Open Work Permits Are Defined

The difference with an open work permit is that it is not limited to one employer. This means that a foreigner worker with an open work permit is legally allowed to work in the majority of the employers in Canada without necessarily obtaining a job offer or LMIA authorization. There might still be some limitations like not being able to work for employers that do not meet the federal compliance requirements, and the worker has far greater flexibility.

In certain cases, like spouses of skilled workers, international graduates or those involved in some immigration pilot programs, these permits are frequently granted. Since open work permits are not associated with a particular employer, they allow freedom to seek improved opportunities, change employment, or relocate to other parts of Canada without losing legal status.

The Right Work Permit

The choice of a closed or an open work permit is based on individual factors and career objectives. A closed work permit can be justified whereby a worker has obtained a stable employment offer with an employer who is ready to pass the LMIA procedure. Conversely, an open work permit can be more suitable when flexibility is required by the worker or where the worker is accompanied by family members.

Many applicants seek the assistance of a professional since the decision has both long-term and legal implications. An immigration lawyer Toronto can go through the options in detail, help workers with applications, and prevent expensive mistakes. Learning to distinguish between the two also means that the workers make sound decisions that will both help them in getting employment in the short term and get them to the long-term immigration objectives.

Legal Consequences Of The Closed Work Permits

Closed work permit legal limitations are important. Employees should pay attention to the conditions of their permit, to the type of work, and the place of work. When they work with another employer without permission, they are said to be working illegally. This may result in deportation, being kicked out of Canada, or even the prohibition of future applications.

There is also a legal responsibility on the part of employers to hire a worker to whom a closed work permit was issued. They are supposed to adhere to federal rules, honor the terms of the LMIA and offer the agreed wages and terms. Employers who do not discharge their obligations will be subject to audit, penalty or, in the future, prohibition of hiring foreign workers.

The Legal Implications of Open Work Permits

The open work permit places more responsibility on the workers who are granted more freedom. Employees are still expected to follow the laws in Canada, report when their condition has changed, and ensure that they are not working in restricted industries. Although an LMIA is not obligatory, the workers still need to retain their legal status by re-renewing the permit in time.

Open work permits allow employers to access foreign talent without having to go through the LMIA process with ease. This does not however imply that they are not bound. Employers have no option but to abide by labor standards and immigration laws, making sure that the rights of the foreign worker are upheld in line with Canadian laws.

Author Profile

Adam Regan

Deputy Editor

Features and account management. 3 years media experience. Previously covered features for online and print editions.

Email Adam@MarkMeets.com