Underrated Fox Shows of All Time Ranked

Fox has solidified its place as a powerhouse among broadcasting companies, standing shoulder to shoulder with the likes of ABC, NBC, and CBS. Since its inception in 1986, Fox has churned out a plethora of shows spanning various genres, often pushing the boundaries of what’s acceptable on primetime television. While the network boasts iconic hits like Family Guy, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Arrested Development, The X-Files, and The Simpsons, its catalog runs much deeper, housing several hidden gems that deserve recognition. From Boston Public to The Mick, here’s a countdown of Fox’s most underrated series that deserve a second look, following a poll of 800 MarkMeets subscribers who responded to our call.

Table of Contents

10. Boston Public (2000-2006)

Starring: Chi McBride, Anthony Heald, Jessalyn Gilsig, Nicky Katt

“Whenever you don’t know what to do, choose the hardest thing because nine times out of ten, that’s the right thing to do.” Boston Public delves into the lives of teachers, administrators, and students at the fictional Winslow High School. Led by Chi McBride as principal Steven Harper, the series navigates the myriad challenges encountered in the education system.

Created by David E. Kelley, the mastermind behind hits like Boston Legal and Ally McBeal, Boston Public offers a compelling portrayal of high school life. Despite a shaky start, the show finds its footing, tackling relevant issues ranging from romance and ambition to sexism and gun violence.

9. Wonderfalls (2004)

Starring: Caroline Dhavernas, Katie Finneran, Tyron Leitso, Lee Pace

“Your sister’s not a cold-blooded murderer. She’s never been a planner.” Wonderfalls follows Jaye Tyler (Caroline Dhavernas), a recent Brown University graduate working at a Niagara Falls gift shop. Her mundane existence takes a bizarre turn when inanimate objects start communicating with her, setting her on whimsical adventures blending comedy and fantasy.

Co-created by Bryan Fuller, Wonderfalls may not have garnered high ratings initially but developed a cult following over time. Caroline Dhavernas shines as the slacker heroine, embodying the laid-back yet snarky Jaye. The series offers a unique blend of humor and whimsy, making it a must-watch for fans of offbeat comedy.

8. Dollhouse (2009-2010)

Starring: Eliza Dushku, Harry Lennix, Fran Kranz, Tahmoh Penikett

“There is no me. I’m just a container.” Dollhouse is set in a near-future world where the Dollhouse organization provides clients with custom personalities and skills implanted into “Actives” or “Dolls.” The story revolves around Echo (Eliza Dushku), one of the Actives who begins to regain fragments of her original identity.

Created by Joss Whedon, Dollhouse offers a captivating blend of action and drama, interspersed with Whedon’s trademark humor. Despite initial reservations about Dushku’s performance, the series boasts strong writing and character development, delving into themes of identity and freedom.

7. Andy Richter Controls the Universe (2002-2003)

Starring: Andy Richter, Paget Brewster, Irene Molloy, Jonathan Slavin

“My mind is full of despair, and my body is full of sex bugs.” This sitcom follows the misadventures of Andy Richter, a hapless writer for a large corporation, as he navigates the mundanity of office life through elaborate daydreams and surreal humor.

Andy Richter Controls the Universe showcases Richter’s comedic prowess, offering a satirical take on corporate culture. While some episodes falter, the series excels in its portrayal of absurd scenarios, elevated by Richter’s amicable yet cynically humorous performance.

6. Grounded for Life (2001-2005)

Starring: Donal Logue, Megyn Price, Lynsey Bartilson, Griffin Frazen

“You’re a degenerate scumbag!” Grounded for Life revolves around the daily trials and tribulations of parents Sean and Claudia, and their three kids, Lily, Jimmy, and Henry. Balancing traditional sitcom elements with innovative storytelling techniques, the series offers a heartfelt portrayal of family life.

Created by Mike Schiff and Bill Martin, Grounded for Life utilizes a mix of studio-taped segments and single-camera scenes to great effect. Despite modest ratings during its initial run, the series found success in syndication, resonating with audiences through its relatable humor and endearing characters.

5. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles (2008-2009)

Starring: Lena Headey, Thomas Dekker, Summer Glau, Richard T. Jones

“The battle for our tomorrow starts today.” Set in the Terminator universe, the series follows Sarah Connor as she protects her son John from the clutches of Skynet, aided by a reprogrammed Terminator named Cameron.

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles offers a captivating blend of action and family drama, enhanced by impressive visual effects and strong performances. Lena Headey delivers a compelling portrayal of Sarah Connor, anchoring the series with her intense and believable performance.

4. Get a Life (1990-1992)

Starring: Chris Elliott, Elinor Donahue, Bob Elliott, Sam Robards

“It took me ten years before I was able to shower in the nude.” Comedian Chris Elliott takes center stage in this absurd sitcom, portraying Chris Peterson, a 30-year-old paperboy with an unconventional approach to life.

Get a Life stands out for its unique brand of humor, characterized by elaborate, surreal, and sarcastic jokes. While the series may not appeal to everyone, its offbeat storytelling and absurd scenarios reflect the influence of comedy luminaries like Charlie Kaufman and Bob Odenkirk.

3. The Ben Stiller Show (1992-1995)

Starring: Ben Stiller, Harry O’Reilly, Amy Stiller, Anne Meara

“I’m a ghost of a phantom of a shadow in the heart of your children!” Before achieving A-list status, Ben Stiller starred in this irreverent sketch comedy show, offering a satirical take on ’80s and ’90s pop culture.

The Ben Stiller Show boasts an eclectic mix of sketches, showcasing Stiller’s comedic talents alongside a talented ensemble cast. While short-lived, the series garnered a cult following and served as a launching pad for the careers of several cast members.

2. Mulaney (2014-2015)

Starring: John Mulaney, Nasim Pedrad, Seaton Smith, Zack Pearlman

“Shut up! You’re all gonna die.” Comedian John Mulaney stars in this sitcom, portraying a fictionalized version of himself navigating the ups and downs of the comedy world.

Mulaney offers a fresh take on the traditional sitcom format, blending observational humor with quirky characters and inventive storytelling. Despite facing criticism upon its release, the series deserves recognition for its unique approach to comedy.

1. The Mick (2017-2018)

Starring: Kaitlin Olson, Sofia Black-D’Elia, Thomas Barbusca, Carla Jimenez

“Listen to me, you can’t just steal owls!” The Mick follows the brash Mackenzie “Mickey” Molng as she assumes guardianship of her sister’s three children, leading to a series of hilarious misadventures.

Led by Kaitlin Olson’s hilarious performance, The Mick offers a fresh take on the family sitcom genre, blending irreverent humor with heartfelt moments. Despite its premature cancellation, the series leaves a lasting impression, earning its place as one of Fox’s most underrated gems.