What Are The 5 Best PC Gaming Controllers for 2023

Microsoft’s Xbox Wireless Controller for the Series X|S consoles is nearly identical to the older Xbox One controller—it adds a Share button for clips and screenshots, uses a USB-C port, and has a redesigned eight-way directional pad, but otherwise the two are hard to tell apart. It’s a proven design that works well, and the vast majority of PC games offer controls and button layouts that assume you’re using an Xbox controller (or one with an Xbox-style button layout). Audio quality from the headset jack is good, for those occasions when you don’t want to connect your headphones directly to your computer. The biggest downside is that you need a pair of AA batteries or a rechargeable battery pack if you want to play wirelessly (most other controllers include a built-in rechargeable battery at this point).

The Sony DualShock 4 Wireless Controller is somewhat smaller than the Xbox controller, making it a more comfortable choice for those with smaller hands. It also has more comfortable control sticks than the Xbox controller, as well as a left-positioned directional pad that’s more comfortable for playing games. It has some nice extra features that the Xbox controller lacks, such as an internal rechargeable battery and a touchpad that can simulate a mouse cursor. But making it work with non-Steam Windows or macOS games takes some extra effort, and headsets plugged into its audio jack don’t work properly with computers unless you buy Sony’s USB wireless adapter. Many games also assume an Xbox button layout, and as a result it can be confusing when the in-game button labels don’t match the buttons on your controller. We like the DualShock 4 better for PC gaming than the PlayStation 5’s DualSense controller, which has the same shortcomings but is physically larger and more expensive.

If you want to spend less and you don’t mind a wire, the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox One/Series X|S gives you most of the features of Microsoft’s newer controller for around half the price. Its analog sticks and buttons are comfortable enough for hours-long gaming sessions, and since it’s compatible with the Xbox console lineup, it takes advantage of the great Xbox controller support built into both Windows and Steam. Compared with other budget controllers, the PowerA controller feels better in the hand, and the audio quality from its headset jack is better. It also has a convenient volume and mute switch and additional configurable buttons on the handles.

If you play retro (or retro-throwback) games that don’t need all the extra buttons, sticks, and triggers of modern controllers, a simpler gamepad can provide a better and more authentic experience. The Retroflag Classic Wired USB Gaming Controller is a dead ringer for the replica Super Nintendo controllers that come with the SNES Classic Edition or the SNES controllers Nintendo makes for the Switch. Its buttons are comfortable, responsive, and clicky, it has a Turbo feature to help with repetitive button mashing, and it works well with Windows, macOS, and most retro gaming software out of the box. But it’s a bad fit for most modern games, which require thumbsticks and more buttons than these old SNES-style controllers have.

If you have an upper-limb disability or injury, you may need a gaming controller that allows for easy remapping of controls. Steam, the dominant PC-gaming platform, provides the best support for Xbox controllers. Our current budget pick, the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S is cheaper than its Microsoft-made counterpart and features mappable “advanced gaming buttons” on the underside of the handles, which makes it much easier for one-handed players to use.