Kent Pecoy on the Rising Cost of Cutting Corners in Coastal Construction

Why the cheapest luxury home in Florida is almost always the most expensive one in the long run, according to a builder who has spent 45 years cleaning up other people’s shortcuts.

Kent Pecoy has a phrase he uses with new clients who arrive in his Southwest Florida offices holding bids from competing builders. He tells them, gently, that they are not comparing the same product.

“People look at two numbers on two pieces of paper and assume they are looking at the same house,” Pecoy said. “They are not. The difference between those numbers is the cost of the things you cannot see. And the things you cannot see are the things that fail first.”

The hidden economics of a custom home

Luxury construction in coastal Florida is one of the most opaque purchases a consumer can make. Unlike a car or a piece of jewelry, the buyer cannot inspect the finished product before committing. Decisions that determine whether a home will perform for 50 years, or fail in the first five, are made inside walls, under slabs, and in the specifications attached to invisible components.

Pecoy, whose firm has built more than 1,500 homes across the region, is direct about where the cuts typically happen. The fasteners that hold a roof assembly together in a Category 4 wind event. The flashing details around windows and doors that determine whether a house keeps water out for two decades or two seasons. The concrete mix and rebar schedule that determines how a foundation behaves when the soil under it shifts. The mechanical systems that determine whether the home is comfortable in August humidity or fights itself for the next 30 years.

None of these decisions show up in a marketing photo. All of them show up on the back end of the warranty period.

“The cheap house is cheap because somebody made a series of decisions you will never see until they fail,” Pecoy said. “And in this climate, they will fail.”

A 45-year track record of repair work

Some of the most instructive parts of Pecoy’s career, he says, are not the homes he built but the homes he was called in to fix. Over four decades, his firm has been hired by second and third owners of homes built by other contractors who promised the same product at a lower price. The pattern, he says, is remarkably consistent.

The original buyer saved 10 to 15 percent on the front end. The next owner spent two to three times that amount addressing structural, envelope, or systems failures within the first decade. By the time Pecoy’s crews arrived, the repair scope often involved opening walls, replacing whole roof assemblies, or remediating water damage that had been working its way through the structure for years.

“I have a pretty good view of what happens when the math is wrong on the front end,” he said. “I have been the guy holding the saw on the back end of those decisions for 40 years.”

What buyers should actually compare

Pecoy’s advice for clients evaluating luxury builders is to stop comparing total project costs and start comparing specifications. A real comparison, he argues, includes the wind rating of the roof system, the impact rating of every opening, the engineering on the foundation, the source and grade of structural lumber, the mechanical brand and warranty, and the tenure of the people who will actually be on the jobsite.

When those line items are put side by side, he says, the price gap between bids almost always explains itself.

“There is no magic in this business,” Pecoy said. “If somebody is 20 percent cheaper than the next guy, they are not smarter. They made 20 percent worth of decisions you are going to live with.”

The long view

For Pecoy, the message to buyers entering the Florida luxury market is not a sales pitch. It is a warning that the industry’s pricing variability is not a reflection of value, but of risk transfer. A builder who quotes lower has, in most cases, transferred risk from his own balance sheet to the homeowner’s future maintenance budget.

“You can pay for quality once, when the house is being built,” he said. “Or you can pay for it over and over again for the rest of the time you own the home. Those are the two options. There is not a third one.”

Author Profile

Adam Regan: Deputy Editor

Features and account management. 7 years media experience. Previously covered features for online and print editions.

Email Adam@MarkMeets.com