Madden NFL 24 Gaming Review

Madden NFL 24: A Decent Yet Unfulfilled Experience

Madden NFL 24, the latest installment in the popular football gaming series, arrives with a mixed bag of improvements and frustrations. While some noteworthy enhancements have been made to the on-field experience, the game still struggles to provide a comprehensive and satisfying overall package. This review delves into the ups and downs of Madden NFL 24, exploring its gameplay improvements, AI enhancements, minigames, and modes.

Enhancements in Gameplay and FieldSENSE

Madden NFL 24 makes strides in refining its gameplay, particularly through its FieldSENSE feature. An integration of the Hit Everything system with new animations has resulted in over 1,700 tackle animations. These animations accurately depict player size and strength, making on-field collisions and tackles feel more realistic and impactful. Notable improvements include new contested-catch animations, wrap-up tackles, and the intriguing addition of “scoop” animations, where large defensive players lift and slam offensive players to the ground. These changes enhance the visceral experience of football gameplay.

Additionally, the Skill-Based Passing system sees improvements with new animations that better represent catching scenarios. The introduction of diving catches adds a spectacular dimension to gameplay, making seemingly unattainable balls more catchable. The game now pays greater attention to player momentum, emphasizing the importance of timing passes to align with receiver movements. These alterations contribute to a more authentic and engaging gameplay experience.

AI Improvements and Realism

Electronic Arts (EA) has invested effort in improving the AI within the game. AI blocking has been significantly enhanced, providing a more sophisticated interaction between blockers. This change is attributed to the application of the FieldSENSE animation system to blockers. The result is a better decision-making process among blockers, leading to improved double-teams, chip blocks, and collaborative efforts. This translates to a more immersive experience in both running and passing plays.

Furthermore, the AI quarterbacks have seen noticeable upgrades. They are now more inclined to employ audibles, hot routes, and strategies similar to their real-life counterparts. This diversification of quarterback behaviors adds a layer of authenticity to the gameplay. Different quarterback types, from improvisational to cautious, exhibit corresponding play styles, enhancing the strategic aspect of the game. Overall, these AI improvements contribute to a more challenging and engaging experience.

Mixed Bag of Minigames

Madden NFL 24 introduces the return of minigames, a feature that had been absent since Madden NFL 13. While the addition is generally welcomed, the execution varies. Some minigames, such as Rushing Attack, offer enjoyable and immersive challenges, while others like Backfield Survival are entertaining but somewhat limited in depth. Unfortunately, some minigames lack substance and feel inconsequential, failing to offer a fulfilling experience.

The reliance on minigames to develop player skills in different modes is a point of contention. While minigames provide an opportunity for skill-building, the requirement to replay them for progress can become repetitive and tiresome. The lack of variety in certain minigames diminishes their appeal and makes the leveling process feel more like a chore.

Modes and Beyond

Madden NFL 24 boasts an array of modes, including Superstar, Franchise, and Ultimate Team. While each mode has received updates, the overall experience remains somewhat predictable for returning players. The Superstar mode, replacing Face of the Franchise, offers a simple storyline but lacks the depth and intrigue of previous story-driven modes. Franchise mode sees improvements with additions like Training Camp and quality-of-life enhancements, but its inherent limitations compared to other sports simulation games are still apparent.

Ultimate Team, despite its controversial mechanics and dominance over other modes, remains a staple of the Madden experience. The mode has seen refinements, making it somewhat more accessible and rewarding for players who choose not to invest heavily. However, concerns about its impact on the overall game experience persist.

The State of Madden NFL 24

Madden NFL 24 embodies the series’ ongoing struggle to strike a balance between on-field excellence and overall game experience. While the gameplay improvements and AI enhancements make for a satisfying football simulation, the game’s off-field aspects, such as menus, UI, and modes, can be frustrating and lackluster. Minigames offer a mixed experience, providing some enjoyable challenges but falling short in variety and significance.

Ultimately, Madden NFL 24 captures the essence of the series’ ongoing evolution. While the game demonstrates progress and effort to address player feedback, there is still work to be done in creating a more cohesive and compelling package. The gaming community awaits a more comprehensive refresh that addresses fundamental issues and elevates Madden NFL to new heights. Until then, Madden NFL 24 remains a decent entry in the series, with glimpses of greatness on the field and room for improvement off of it.

Author Profile

Jabeen Panchaya
Writer and Reviewer


Leave a Reply